Jake Lawson here. After 15+ years evaluating LLC formation services for my clients, I’ve tested dozens of providers across the spectrum. MyLLC represents the old guard of business formation—they’ve been around since 1998, they wrote “LLCs for Dummies,” and they’ve formed thousands of businesses. But longevity doesn’t always equal excellence in today’s competitive market. Here’s my honest assessment after extensive testing.
Bottom line up front: MyLLC is a decent middle-tier option with solid customer service and reasonable pricing on add-on services, but their bare-bones LLC formation lacks value compared to modern competitors.
⭐⭐⭐ 3/5 stars – Adequate service with some dated elements
MyLLC at a Glance
Founded: 1998 (26+ years in business)
Headquarters: Cheyenne, Wyoming
Core offering: A la carte LLC formation services
Base price: $99 + state fees + $24 shipping
Best for: Entrepreneurs who want to pick and choose specific services
Avoid if: You want comprehensive packages or cutting-edge user experience
What I Like About MyLLC
1. A La Carte Flexibility
Unlike most providers that force you into packages, MyLLC lets you buy exactly what you need. Want just basic formation? Pay $99. Need registered agent service? Add $149/year. This approach works well for experienced entrepreneurs who know exactly what they want.
Why this matters: Many competitors bundle services you may not need, inflating costs. MyLLC’s approach gives you control.
2. Solid Customer Service
I tested both their phone and chat support. The chat representative was particularly helpful—knowledgeable, responsive, and even suggested I have an attorney review my operating agreement. Phone support was more basic but accurate.
Real-world test: Asked complex questions about multi-state operations and got detailed, correct answers via chat.
3. Fast Internal Processing
MyLLC processes formation documents within 24-48 hours, which beats many competitors. They review everything with you before filing, reducing errors.
Important caveat: They don’t offer expedited state processing, so while they’re fast internally, you can’t accelerate the state approval process.
4. Transparent Pricing
No hidden fees or surprise costs. What you see is what you pay, which I appreciate in an industry full of bait-and-switch tactics.
What Concerns Me About MyLLC
1. Poor Value for Basic Formation
$99 + $24 shipping + state fees for bare-bones formation is expensive compared to modern competitors. You’re paying $123 plus state fees for essentially just filing paperwork.
Better alternatives: Northwest Registered Agent charges $39 + state fees and includes registered agent service for the first year.
2. Outdated User Experience
MyLLC’s website and ordering process feels like 2005. Clunky interface, finicky hover menus, and dated design elements that make the experience frustrating.
Why this matters: In today’s market, user experience reflects operational efficiency. If they can’t modernize their website, what else are they behind on?
3. Limited State Knowledge
While their reps know the basics, I found gaps in state-specific knowledge that more specialized providers handle better.
Example: Asked about Idaho-specific compliance requirements and got generic answers that didn’t address Idaho’s unique rules.
4. Questionable Formation State Recommendations
MyLLC will form your LLC in any state without proper guidance about whether that’s actually beneficial. This can create expensive foreign registration requirements.
Red flag: Many clients end up with Delaware or Nevada LLCs when their home state would be better and cheaper.
Service Breakdown: What You Actually Get
Basic LLC Formation ($99 + $24 shipping)
- Name availability check (you can do this free yourself)
- Articles of Organization preparation and filing
- Email confirmation when filed
My assessment: Overpriced for what you receive. No registered agent, no operating agreement, no ongoing support.
Add-On Services (Reasonably Priced)
EIN Service ($69): Fair price, though you can get EINs free directly from the IRS
DBA Registration ($99): Standard industry pricing
Foreign Qualification ($149): Competitive rate for multi-state businesses
Registered Agent ($149/year): Slightly above average but includes mail forwarding and shredding
Important: If you don’t live or operate your business in the state where Harbor Compliance forms your LLC, you’ll have to register it as a Foreign LLC in your home state. This requires maintaining two LLC filings, paying two sets of state filing fees, and hiring two Registered Agents.
For guidance on choosing the right location, see our guide on the Best State to Form an LLC.
Services I’d Skip
Corporate Kit ($69): Overpriced for basic templates and binder you can create yourself
Managed Report Service ($49/year + state fees): Limited state availability and you can file reports yourself easily
MyLLC vs. Top Competitors
vs. Northwest Registered Agent
MyLLC: $123 + state fees for basic formation
Northwest: $39 + state fees including first year registered agent
Winner: Northwest by a landslide
vs. ZenBusiness
MyLLC: A la carte flexibility, older but stable
ZenBusiness: Modern packages, better user experience, comparable pricing
Winner: ZenBusiness for most users
vs. LegalZoom
MyLLC: More transparent pricing, better customer service
LegalZoom: Bigger brand, more marketing, higher prices
Winner: MyLLC if you must choose between them
Who Should Consider MyLLC
Good fit for:
- Experienced entrepreneurs: Who know exactly what services they need
- Cost-conscious buyers: Who want specific add-ons without package bloat
- Traditional business owners: Who prefer phone support and established companies
Not ideal for:
- First-time business owners: Who need comprehensive guidance and modern tools
- Tech-savvy entrepreneurs: Who expect smooth, modern user experiences
- Budget-focused buyers: Who want maximum value for basic formation
Red Flags I’ve Noticed
1. Price-Match Claims
MyLLC advertises price matching, but customer reviews suggest they require extensive documentation and make the process difficult.
2. Terms of Service Complexity
Their legal terms are dense and hard to understand, which creates potential for customer confusion about cancellation and refund policies.
3. Limited Geographic Insight
While they operate nationwide, their Wyoming base means less specific knowledge about complex state requirements in places like California or New York.
Tip: To remove a Registered Agent, an LLC must first file paperwork with the state to appoint a replacement. This is because almost every state requires LLCs to keep a Registered Agent on record to accept Service of Process.
MyLLC’s Registered Agent Service: Separate Analysis
Price: $149/year
Service quality: Solid but unremarkable
Unique features: Mail shredding for unwanted documents
Comparison: Competitive but not exceptional
My take: Adequate registered agent service, but Northwest and others offer better value with more comprehensive features.
The Verdict: When MyLLC Makes Sense
MyLLC is a reliable, if unexciting, option for specific situations:
Choose MyLLC if:
- You want a la carte service selection
- You value established companies with long track records
- You need specific add-on services at reasonable prices
- You don’t mind dated user interfaces
Choose alternatives if:
- You want maximum value for basic formation (Northwest)
- You prefer modern, streamlined experiences (ZenBusiness)
- You need extensive state-specific guidance (specialized providers)
- You’re forming your first business and need comprehensive support
My Honest Recommendation
For most entrepreneurs: Skip MyLLC in favor of Northwest Registered Agent ($39 + state fees with first-year registered agent included) or ZenBusiness for better value and modern experience.
For experienced business owners: MyLLC could work if you specifically value a la carte pricing and don’t mind paying premium for basic formation.
For anyone: Avoid their basic $99 formation package—there are much better values available in today’s market.
Quick Decision Framework
If you need: Just basic LLC formation →
Choose Northwest ($39 vs MyLLC’s $123)
If you want: Specific add-on services →
Consider MyLLC for reasonable upsell pricing
If you prefer: Comprehensive packages →
Choose ZenBusiness for modern experience
If you require: White-glove service →
Hire a local attorney for personalized guidance
Final Thoughts
MyLLC represents the middle of the pack in today’s LLC formation market. They’re not bad, but they’re not exceptional either. Their longevity and “LLCs for Dummies” credentials give them credibility, but credibility doesn’t justify paying 3x more for basic formation when superior alternatives exist.
In 15+ years evaluating these services, I’ve learned that the best providers combine competitive pricing, modern user experience, and genuine customer focus. MyLLC hits one of those three consistently.
My recommendation: Unless you have specific reasons to choose MyLLC (like needing their particular mix of a la carte services), you’ll get better value and experience elsewhere.
Looking for my top LLC formation recommendations? I maintain updated rankings of the best services based on extensive testing and client feedback. Northwest Registered Agent consistently tops my list for value and service quality.
About Jake Lawson: LLC Formation Strategist and Tax Advisor with 15+ years helping entrepreneurs choose the right business structures and service providers. I’ve personally tested dozens of formation services and helped over 1,200 clients launch compliant businesses. No affiliate relationships influence my reviews—just honest assessments based on real-world testing and client outcomes.